How to hire a Content Writer

Why this role is hard to hire

The hiring challenge

Writer portfolios are inherently misleading because writers know how to polish their samples. The best piece in a portfolio may have gone through five rounds of editing with a senior editor. The real test is whether the candidate can produce good work in your voice, under your constraints, on a tight turnaround — not whether their portfolio looks impressive. Additionally, many content writers are strong stylists but weak researchers: they can write beautifully about nothing. The interview needs to test for both writing ability and substance.

What to look for in a Content Writer

Four traits matter: Clarity (can they explain a complex idea in simple language without dumbing it down?). Voice adaptability (can they shift tone from formal to conversational depending on the audience?). Research ability (can they write about a topic they do not know well by doing research and interviewing subject matter experts?). Editing instinct (can they cut their own work ruthlessly, removing words that do not earn their place?).

For Indian companies, also check for comfort writing in Indian English (which has its own conventions different from American or British English), ability to localise content for Indian audiences (references, examples, and cultural context that resonate locally), and experience with SEO if the role requires it — many Indian content roles blend content marketing with search engine optimisation.

Common mistakes when hiring Content Writers

Judging by portfolio alone. A portfolio shows the best work after multiple edits. Give the candidate a timed writing exercise to see what they produce under realistic conditions. The gap between polished portfolio and first-draft quality reveals the real skill level.

Not testing for research ability. A writer who can only write about topics they already know will be stuck whenever you need content on a new subject. Ask them to write about something unfamiliar and see whether they ask good questions or produce shallow content.

Hiring for volume instead of quality. A writer who produces 10 mediocre articles a week is less valuable than one who produces 3 excellent ones. Be clear about what you value and test for it.

What to test

Key skills for a Content Writer

• Clear, concise writing
• Brand voice adaptation
• Research and subject matter interviewing
• SEO fundamentals
• Editing and self-revision
• Writing under deadline pressure
• Audience awareness and tone shifting
• Content structure and storytelling

Sample questions

What a great interview looks like

Every question is from the GoodFit library. Customize the rubric for your context in the platform.

Suggested format

Recommended interview process